Important Claim Phone Numbers

Personal Lines Claim Phone Numbers

Personal Lines – Claims Phone Numbers

Aegis Insurance Company – 800-233-2160

(option 1 for homes, new claims option 1, existing claims option 2)

American Modern Home Insurance – 800-375-2075

(new claims option 2, existing claims option 3)

Arbella – 800-272-3552 

(new or existing claims option 1)

AMWINS – 404-751-4390

(new or existing claims option 1)

Barnstable County Mutual– 800-310-9310 

Grundy – 800-765-9749

(new claims option 3, existing claims option 2)

Hagerty – 800-385-0274

(new claims option 1, existing claims option 2, roadside assistance option 4)

Homeowners Choice – 888-210-5235

(new claims option 2, existing claims option 3)

Jewelers Mutual – 888-884-2424

(new or existing claims option 5)

Kingstone – 800-364-7045

(new or existing claims option 3)

Lexington Insurance Company – 800-931-9546

(new claims option 2, existing claims option 1)

Mapfre (Commerce) – 800-221-1605

(press 2 and follow prompts for claims)

MPIUA (Fair Plan) – 800-851-8978 

(new or existing claims option 1)

Norfolk & Dedham – 800-688-1825 

(new or existing claims opt 1)

PersonalUmbrella.com

(contact Underwriting Manager, Eric Stewart 510-420-2832)

Plymouth Rock and Bunker Hill – 844-346-1225 

(home claims, opt 1, auto glass claims 2 auto claims 3, existing claims opt 4)

Progressive – 800-274-4499

(follow prompts for claims)

RLI – 800-444-0406

(new or existing claims option 4)

Scottsdale Insurance Company – 800-423-7675

(new claims option 1, existing claims option 2)

Travelers – 800-252-4633 

(new claims option 1, existing claims option 2, roadside assistance option 3)

Typtap – 844-289-7968

(new claims option 1, existing claims option 2)

USLI – 888-523-5545

(new or existing claims option 3)

Marine Claims Phone Numbers

Travelers – 800-252-4633 

(new claims option 1, existing claims option 2, roadside assistance option 3)

Chubb – 800-252-4670 

(new or existing claims option 1)

OneBeacon – 877-248-3455 

(new claims option 1, existing claims option 2)

New Hampshire – 888-760-9195 

(new or existing claims option 3)

North American Specialty Insurance – 800-882-5414 

(new or existing claims option 1)

Berkley – 855-486-0320 

Markel – 800-236-2637 

(new or existing claims option 2)

Progressive – 800-274-4499

(follow prompts for claims)